Technext Technext
  • Home
  • Stories
    • Kenyan Insurtech Pula Closes $6M Series A to Boost Profits for Small-scale Farmers Across Africa
      Kenyan Insurtech Pula Closes $6M Series A to Boost Profits for Small-scale Farmers Across Africa
      3 hours ago 0
      57
    • Tech Events this Week: StartupBlink Ecosystem Summit, 2021 Commodities Outlook and Others
      Tech Events this Week: StartupBlink Ecosystem Summit, 2021 Commodities Outlook and Others
      7 hours ago 0
      46
    • App Review: Sety Let’s You Know if there’s Danger Around and When the Coast is Clear
      App Review: Sety Let’s You Know if there’s Danger Around and When the Coast is Clear
      1 day ago 0
      46
    • Social Media Roundup: #InaugurationDay, NIMC and Other Stories that Trended
      Social Media Roundup: #InaugurationDay, NIMC and Other Stories that Trended
      2 days ago 0
      94
    • Global Tech Roundup: President Biden Reverses Nigeria’s Travel Ban
      Global Tech Roundup: President Biden Reverses Nigeria’s Travel Ban
      3 days ago 0
      114
    • Nigerians React as NRC Launches N900 million Railway e-Ticketing Platform
      Nigerians React as NRC Launches N900 million Railway e-Ticketing Platform
      3 days ago 0
      186
    • Alphabet Shuts down Balloon-powered Internet in Kenya Months after its Launching
      Alphabet Shuts down Balloon-powered Internet in Kenya Months after its Launching
      3 days ago 0
      133
    • Google Search And Facebook News Could Leave Australia if Forced to Pay News Publishers
      Google Search And Facebook News Could Leave Australia if Forced to Pay News Publishers
      3 days ago 0
      106
    • Movie Review: ‘Outside the Wire’ is an Explosive Action Thriller Showing the Dangers of Sentient AI
      Movie Review: ‘Outside the Wire’ is an Explosive Action Thriller Showing the Dangers of Sentient AI
      4 days ago 0
      140
  • Features
    • Sell it or Repurpose it, Here are 5 Things You Could do With your Old Gadgets and Devices
      Sell it or Repurpose it, Here are 5 Things You Could do With your Old Gadgets and Devices
      4 days ago 0
      128
    • 5 Tips to Make Your Business More Popular on Social Media
      5 Tips to Make Your Business More Popular on Social Media
      2 weeks ago 0
      236
    • Analysts Forecast Bitcoin to Hit $100k in 2021, But is This Really a Good Time to Start Buying?
      Analysts Forecast Bitcoin to Hit $100k in 2021, But is This Really a Good Time to Start Buying?
      2 weeks ago 0
      401
    • Top 5 Most In-Demand Tech Jobs for 2021 — and Skills Required for them
      Top 5 Most In-Demand Tech Jobs for 2021 — and Skills Required for them
      2 weeks ago 0
      458
    • Financial Strategies for Surviving 2021 with Ayo Akinmade, Vice Chairman, Regus
      Financial Strategies for Surviving 2021 with Ayo Akinmade, Vice Chairman, Regus
      3 weeks ago 0
      423
    • ‘Expect Aggressive Expansion in 2021’- PlentyWaka’s Johnny Enagwolor on Surviving 2020 and What the Future Holds
      ‘Expect Aggressive Expansion in 2021’- PlentyWaka’s Johnny Enagwolor on Surviving 2020 and What the Future Holds
      4 weeks ago 0
      471
    • After a Poor 2020, Here are the Top Cinema Trends to Watch Out for in 2021
      After a Poor 2020, Here are the Top Cinema Trends to Watch Out for in 2021
      4 weeks ago 0
      419
  • Reviews
    • Tech Events this Week: StartupBlink Ecosystem Summit, 2021 Commodities Outlook and Others
      Tech Events this Week: StartupBlink Ecosystem Summit, 2021 Commodities Outlook and Others
      7 hours ago 0
      46
    • Global Tech Roundup: President Biden Reverses Nigeria’s Travel Ban
      Global Tech Roundup: President Biden Reverses Nigeria’s Travel Ban
      3 days ago 0
      114
    • Movie Review: ‘Outside the Wire’ is an Explosive Action Thriller Showing the Dangers of Sentient AI
      Movie Review: ‘Outside the Wire’ is an Explosive Action Thriller Showing the Dangers of Sentient AI
      4 days ago 0
      140
    • You Can’t Get Your NIN Slip Through the NIMC App but Here are 3 Things You Can Do With it
      You Can’t Get Your NIN Slip Through the NIMC App but Here are 3 Things You Can Do With it
      5 days ago 0
      200
    • Netflix Surpasses 200 Million Subscribers, Says It no Longer Needs External Financing
      Netflix Surpasses 200 Million Subscribers, Says It no Longer Needs External Financing
      5 days ago 0
      134
    • With Growing Interest in Forex Trading, Here are 5 Best Forex Brokers in Nairaland, Nigeria
      With Growing Interest in Forex Trading, Here are 5 Best Forex Brokers in Nairaland, Nigeria
      6 days ago 0
      155
    • Kenya Overtakes Nigeria as Africa’s Favorite Investment Destination
      Kenya Overtakes Nigeria as Africa’s Favorite Investment Destination
      6 days ago 0
      284
  • Women in Tech
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
Go to...

    Controversy Trails Nigeria’s Proposed Infectious Diseases Bill, But is it as Bad as People Claim?

    Tomiwa OnaleyeTomiwa Onaleye
    9 months ago
    Controversy Trails Nigeria’s Proposed Infectious Diseases Bill, But is it as Bad as People Claim?

    Last week, the Infectious Diseases Bill to help the country handle disease outbreaks passed its second reading at the Federal House of Representatives. However, controversy about what the bill entails has sprouted outcries against it, especially on social media.

    The Infectious Diseases Bill, which was sponsored by the Speaker of the Federal House of Representatives, Femi Gbajabiamila, is supposed to replace the National Quarantine Act by providing special powers that would allow the government to curb outbreaks.

    Nigerians let's check this out and save our Nation from DICTATORSHIP!!!!#opposeBill!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Check out Draft Control of Infectious Diseases Bill on Scribd: @Scribd ReadMore https://t.co/uzEh3VMUlq

    — 🇳🇬🇨🇳 Obong Innocent 🇸🇪 (@MrOffiong007) May 4, 2020

    With the current COVID-19 outbreak ravaging the country, one would expect that such a bill should be lauded by the public. On the contrary, the bill has been met with strong opposition with several Nigerians claiming it creates more problems than it purports to solve.

    COVID-19 has infected more than 2,800 people and killed more than 90 in Nigeria

    Riddled with questions, I examined the Infectious Diseases Bill to ascertain if it is as bad as people claim.

    Breaking: Death Rate Soars as NCDC Records 220 New Coronavirus Cases in Nigeria, 62 in Lagos

    Coincidence or Plagiarism

    The first red flag I discovered about the bill is that, just as people claimed, it was actually plagiarised from the infectious disease act of another country. The 43-draft of the infectious disease bill is over 90% plagiarised from Singapore’s Infectious Disease Act of 1977.

    What this means that the speaker who proposed the bill without research and probably no consultation with relevant bodies as to what the country really needs to fight an outbreak, copied word for word a law enacted for use during the70’s.

    Infectious Diseases Bill draft Credit: The ICIR

    What makes this revelation more troubling is the fact the Act that was copied was enacted at a time when Singapore was still a one-party state. For a country operating a democratic system of government, completely absorbing the law of a country with a history of dictatorship is a danger to the freedom of democracy.

    Saviour or Dictator

    Examing the first few sections of the bill, the issues addressed and the power granted to the Director-General (DG) of the Nigerian Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) appears justifiable as it addressed some of the measures needed to prevent spread during an outbreak.

    With the fatalities close 100 and the current situation in Kano State where religious practices are affecting the proper handling of people who died with symptoms of COVID-19, empowering the government with a better solution to handle the situation could be a saviour.

    For example, the Section 7 and 12 of the bill, which gives the DG of the NCDC power to acquire corpse suspected to have died of suspicious symptoms without confirmation for proper autopsy, as well as the power to ensure that corpses of those infected be disposed properly to protect public safety.

    However, critics have said the Infectious Diseases Bill basically makes the DG of NCDC an unelected dictator. According to them, the bill is more about making the DG of NCDC and the Minister of Health become unjustifiably powerful.

    Although their claims may seem audacious, Section 15 shows a troubling provision. Under the section, the DG has the power to declare any house an isolation area or order the arrest of any person attempting to leave such an area.

    “The Minister may, for the purpose of preventing the spread of possible outbreak of infectious disease, by notification in the Gazette declare any premises to be an isolation area…A person who leaves or attempts to leave or is suspected of having left an isolation area in contravention of an order under subsection (3) may be arrested without warrant by any police officer, or by any Health Officer authorised in writing in that behalf by the Director-General.”

    Extract from infectious diseases bill – Section 15

    Arresting without warrant means a police officer on the order from the DG can arrest and detain someone without any proof, all he needs is “suspicion”.

    According to a political analyst, Oluniyi Gates, a person so arrested will have no right to a lawyer as their fate will be in the hands of DG NCDC and Minister, not a capable court of law.

    This raises concerns that the bill empowers a form of dictatorship as it effectively removes constitutionally guaranteed right to assumed innocence and fair hearing. Also, more troubling it gives the power to detain without proof to the police force which is notorious for its brutality and flagrant abuse of power.

    Similarly, in Section 24, the police are given the power to arrest anyone who is suffering from an infectious disease. The ambiguity of this section is threatening as the section give police the right to arrest you even if the infectious disease you have isn’t easily communicable or peradventure are merely symptoms of flu, which is pretty common.

    DG with Presidential powers

    Although Section 20 gives the DG power to stop an event like a concert which may cause the spread of disease during an outbreak, the clause can be easily misinterpreted to trample on the right to freedom of association.

    Chikwe Ihekweazu, the director-general of the Nigeria Centre for Disease Control,

    “Where it appears to the Director General that the holding of any meeting, gathering or any public entertainment is likely to increase the spread of any infectious disease, the Director General may by order prohibit or restrict, subject to such conditions as he may think fit, for a period not exceeding 14 days, the meeting, gathering or public entertainment in any place.”

    Extract from Infectious Diseases Bill – Section 20

    In practice, wordings are important in law and this particular provision can easily be taken to mean the DG has the power to cancel any form of gathering. This is especially dangerous as the power could be weaponized politically.

    It gets more troubling, Section 71 gives the DG and his enforcers in the police and paramilitary forces the judicial immunity attributed to the president during an outbreak.

    No liability shall lie personally against the Director-General, any Health Officer, any Port Health Officer, any police officer or any authorised person who, acting in good faith and with reasonable care, does or omits to do anything in the execution or purported execution of this Act. ”

    Extract from Infectious Diseases Bill – Section 71

    The scary interpretation of this is that the DG and his enforces will not be held accountable for what they use the power for. In essence, any misuse of power by security agencies either harassment or unjustified killing will not be tried by a Nigerian court.

    Other Controversial Sections of the Infectious Diseases Bill

    Another controversial section in the bill includes Section 8, which makes it compulsory for the doctor or any medical practitioner to forgo doctor-patient confidentiality and release medical details and records of any patient to the DG at his request. However, I don’t see much wrong with this section as long as it is confined to the duration of the outbreak

    Controversy Trails Nigeria's Infectious Diseases Bill, But is it as Bad as They Claim?

    In Section 55, the DG was given the power to request any book, document or information and also forcefully enter premises without warrants to obtain such information. This section is especially threatening to freedom of the press as it gives leeway to assault on journalists and whistleblowers who are at loggerheads with the DG.

    Generally, anyone found guilty of an offence under the bill will be fined about N100,000 or be imprisoned for a term not exceeding 6 months. for subsequent offences, the person will be fined N200,000 or imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or to both.

    Summary

    The proposed Infectious Diseases Bill in truth poses a lot of concerns. Its tone and clumsiness of the wordings make the bill very dangerous if passed.

    The Director-General of NCDC, Chikwe Ihekweazu, has pointed out that he wasn’t involved in the drafting of the bill and that it requires further consultation. He also added that he is not in favour of drafting a bill at this time.

    “I’m personally not in favor of drafting a bill in the middle of a crisis,”

    Chikwe Ihekweazu, the director general of the Nigeria Centre for Disease Control,

    However, if this bill gets enough votes during voting next week, it will come very close to being approved and forwarded to the Senate. Although the DG may not want the nightmarish power the bill entails, if passed, it will give anyone who ever becomes DG Presidential powers.

    In the past Nigerians have been able to stall unwanted bills like the Social media bill and Hate speech bill. With education already building on the potential danger of the bill, there is good hope that Nigerians will stall this bill too.


    If you’d like to get featured on our Entrepreneur Spotlight, click here to share your startup story with us.


    SUBSCRIBE

    Get latest Technology news, reviews, business-related content with a deliberate emphasis on the African narrative and insightful analysis in Nigeria – straight to your inbox.


    Comments

    Share :
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Google+
    • Pinterest
    • Linkedin
    • Email
    Tomiwa Onaleye

    Tomiwa Onaleye

    Tomiwa Onaleye is a content writer that mines emotion bred from words. He is an avid lover of gadgets and Tech World. He graduated with B.Sc Mechanical from the prestigious University of Ibadan.

    After Zoom, Hackers Turn to Microsoft Teams as Reports Show Spike in Cyberattacks
    Next article
    After Zoom, Hackers Turn to Microsoft Teams as Reports Show Spike in Cyberattacks
    Breaking: Nigeria Records Highest Daily Covid-19 Cases On First Day of Returning to Work
    Previous article
    Breaking: Nigeria Records Highest Daily Covid-19 Cases On First Day of Returning to Work

    Related Posts

    • Stories 3 hours ago

      Kenyan Insurtech Pula Closes $6M Series A to Boost Profits for Small-scale Farmers Across Africa

      Kenyan Insurtech Pula Closes $6M Series A to Boost Profits for Small-scale Farmers Across Africa
      Reviews, Stories 7 hours ago

      Tech Events this Week: StartupBlink Ecosystem Summit, 2021 Commodities Outlook and Others

      Tech Events this Week: StartupBlink Ecosystem Summit, 2021 Commodities Outlook and Others
      Stories 1 day ago

      App Review: Sety Let's You Know if there's Danger Around and When the Coast is Clear

      App Review: Sety Let’s You Know if there’s Danger Around and When the Coast is Clear
    • Stories 2 days ago

      Social Media Roundup: #InaugurationDay, NIMC and Other Stories that Trended

      Social Media Roundup: #InaugurationDay, NIMC and Other Stories that Trended
      Reviews, Stories 3 days ago

      Global Tech Roundup: President Biden Reverses Nigeria's Travel Ban

      Global Tech Roundup: President Biden Reverses Nigeria’s Travel Ban
      Stories 3 days ago

      Nigerians React as NRC Launches N900 million Railway e-Ticketing Platform

      Nigerians React as NRC Launches N900 million Railway e-Ticketing Platform

    Bitcoin Recent Prices

    Brandest

    Sign up for Newsletters

    Popular News

    • Meet Koko Networks, the Energy Company Bringing Bio-Ethanol Cooking Fuel to Kenyan Homes
      Meet Koko Networks, the Energy Company Bringing Bio-Ethanol Cooking Fuel to Kenyan Homes
      June 11, 2019 0
    • Are you an Early-Stage Startup? Get Ready to Pitch at the Startup Compound MVP Demo Day
      Are you an Early-Stage Startup? Get Ready to Pitch at the Startup Compound MVP Demo Day
      June 12, 2018 0
    • Startup Review: Agriple Helps Farmers Sell Directly to Consumers, but You Have to Buy in Bulk
      Startup Review: Agriple Helps Farmers Sell Directly to Consumers, but You Have to Buy in Bulk
      5 months ago 0
    • Weekly Roundup: Nigerians React as MultiChoice Increases DSTV Subscription Rates
      Weekly Roundup: Nigerians React as MultiChoice Increases DSTV Subscription Rates
      August 10, 2018 0
    • Breaking: Nigeria’s Recovery Rate Hits All-Time High of 27% as NCDC Reports 226 New Coronavirus Cases
      Breaking: Nigeria's Recovery Rate Hits All-Time High of 27% as NCDC Reports 226 New Coronavirus Cases
      8 months ago 0

    Follow Us

    Latest Tweets

    • technextdotng RT @aforisms_: Kenyan Insurtech Pula Closes $6M Series A to Boost Profits for Small-scale Farmers Across Africa - https://t.co/7lVP7nECvp v…
      about an hour ago
    • technextdotng RT @Gbemileke_B: Kenyan insurtech startup @AdvisorsPula has raised $6M in Series A funding to scale up its tech-driven insurance products f…
      about an hour ago
    • technextdotng Kenyan #insurtech startup, @AdvisorsPula has raised $6 million in a Series A funding round to increase profitabilit… https://t.co/gO877ECh1R
      about an hour ago
    • technextdotng New post: Kenyan Insurtech Pula Closes $6M Series A to Boost Profits for Small-scale Farmers Across Africa https://t.co/5JQufzhXbe
      about 3 hours ago

    Instagram

    technextdotng

    Technext.ng is the go-to site for news, reviews and insightful analysis in the Nigerian tech space.
    http://ow.ly/ayTM30mSlGS

    With the realization of one’s own potential and With the realization of one’s own potential and self-confidence in one’s ability, one can build a better world.
#TechNext #MondayMotivation
    72.8% of our voters opt to give out their old devi 72.8% of our voters opt to give out their old devices or go with the flow of things.

What do you do?
#Smartphone #gadget #Polls
    Top App Downloads in Africa (2020) 1. Egypt - 2.3 Top App Downloads in Africa (2020)
1. Egypt - 2.3 billion
2. S/Africa - 680 million
3. Nigeria - 640 million

Read more at technext.ng
#Payments #Africa #Fintech #Finance #Innovation #Technology #Nigeria #SouthAfrica #Egypt #Consumer #Kenya #Report #Gaming #Gamers
    Highest In-app Spending in Africa (2020) 1. S/Afri Highest In-app Spending in Africa (2020)
1. S/Africa - $210 million
2. Egypt - $120 million
3. Nigeria - $60 million

Read more at technext.ng
#Payments #Africa #Fintech #Finance #Innovation #Technology #Nigeria #SouthAfrica #Egypt #Consumer #Kenya #MobileApp #App
    According to our latest poll results, the ride hai According to our latest poll results, the ride hailing battle in Nigeria is still between Uber and Bolt, with both clinching 77.8% of the votes.

#RideHailing #Nigeria #Polls
    Happy birthday to the in-house "techie", @Tommy_bl Happy birthday to the in-house "techie", @Tommy_blanc.
Best wishes from all of us at Technext. @te

#WeAreTechnext #HappyBirthday
    Load More... Follow on Instagram

    Random News

    • Five Incredible Things We Noticed About the Zenbook Pro Duo
      Five Incredible Things We Noticed About the Zenbook Pro Duo
      7 months ago 0

      If you have been following the ASUS brand, you will know that ASUS is no stranger to innovation. ASUS ...

      Read More
    Copyright 2020 technext.ng | Privacy Policy | Media Policy